maternity care coalition donatecontactsitemapsearch
programs
home
about
programs
  MOMobile
  Early Head Start
  MOMobile at Riverside
  Cribs for Kids
 

•  Maternity Care in Southeastern PA

 

   •  Babies Don't Have to 

      Wait in Norristown

 

    Maternity Units           diAccess

     Prenatal Care Access

     Insurance

   Childbirth at a     

      Crossroads report

 

•  Maternity Services Advocacy

 

•  Federal Health Care Reform

 

•  Take Action!

 

•  Babies Are Born to Breastfeed

  Research
  HIV/AIDS Prevention & Education
events
resources
news
Support MCC

Prenatal Care Barriers in Chester, Norristown, and Philadelphia

Barriers - long waits, fewer practitioners - are faced by pregnant women on Medicaid seeking prenatal care in the city of Chester, Norristown and in Philadelphia.

 

All MCOs

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

City of Chester 2010

154

18

3  weeks*

Norristown 2010 27* 7 11.5 weeks

Philadelphia 2007

 

1,519 139 2.4 weeks

*Wait time ranges 3 days to 33 days

 

City of Chester in Delaware County

MCC investigated the experiences of women on Medicaid in search of prenatal care in the city of Chester. The charts below reveal that of 154 practitioners listed, only 18 were available, three of whom are only part-time. The average wait was 3 weeks for an initial appointment.

Pregnant women in the city of Chester have only one maternity unit available at the city's sole hospital, Crozer-Chester Medical Center. The hospital accepts just one of the five Medicaid insurance plans (Keystone Mercy Health Plan). Even for this pool of Medicaid patients that can access care at the hospital, there are often other barriers:

  • Keystone Mercy Health Plan stopped enrolling new members from February to October 1, 2010. No new recipients of Medicaid were able to access non-emergency care at the hospital during that time.
  • Crozer-Keystone Health System manages both Crozer-Chester Medical Center and Riddle Memorial Hospital, two of the three hospitals in Delaware County. The health system announced March, 2010 that they would end their contract with Keystone Mercy, leaving many families wondering where they would get care. In the end, Crozer-Chester renewed the contract on the day it was set to expire in late April, long after all Keystone Mercy members received notices that their insurance was no longer accepted.

Beginning in the summer of 2010 two new Medicaid health plans (Aetna Better Health and CoventryCares) developed contracts with prenatal care practitioners in Chester.

 

Prenatal appointments in the city of Chester (all MCOs)

All MCOs 

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

September, 2010

154

18

3  weeks*

*Wait time ranges 3 days to 33 days

 

 

Keystone Mercy

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

September, 2010

31

17

3  weeks*

*Wait time ranges 3 days to 33 days

 

AmeriChoice

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

September, 2010

3

0

N/A

 

Health Partners 

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

September, 2010

1

0

N/A

 

Aetna Better Health

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

September, 2010

36

12

2.5 weeks

 

Coventry Cares

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

September, 2010

19

17

3  weeks*

*Wait time ranges 3 days to 33 days

 
 

Norristown in Montgomery County (2005-2010)

 
MCC staff annually call each listed practitioner for all Medicaid managed care organizations (MCOs) for Norristown to learn how long the wait is for the first available prenatal care appointment. The charts below summarize what we have learned.  
 

The average wait time for an initial prenatal care appointment in August 2010 was a shocking 11.5 weeks, just shy of a full trimester. Equally disturbing, of the 6 available practitioners, none accepted the two new Medicaid plans, Aetna Better Health and CoventryCares.

With the closure of Mercy Suburban hospital in February 2010, and the lack of other prenatal care options, there is only 1 clinic to serve all pregnant women on Medicaid in Norristown.  We need to do better for Norristown families!

Prenatal appointments in Norristown (all MCOs)

All MCOs 

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available*

Average wait time for an appointment

August, 2005

115

15

6 weeks

August, 2006

87

15

5.5 weeks

August, 2007

64 12 2.9 weeks

August, 2008

53 10 3 weeks
August, 2009 105 12 4 weeks
August, 2010 47 6 11.5 weeks

*These numbers reflect the actual number of practitioners among the five MCOs, excluding duplicates among their lists. 

 

The charts below show the individual data collected for each of the five managed care organizations (MCOs). 

Keystone Mercy Health Plan: Prenatal appointments in Norristown

Keystone Mercy Health Plan

 

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available

Average wait time for an appointment

August, 2005

69

6

5 weeks

August, 2006

32

11

5 weeks

August, 2007

33

11 3 weeks

August, 2008

26 9 3 weeks
August, 2009 78 9 4 weeks
August, 2010 47 6 11.5 weeks

AmeriChoice: Prenatal appointments in Norristown

AmeriChoice

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available

Average wait time for an appointment

August, 2005

24

2

7 weeks

August, 2006

17

10

7.5 weeks

August, 2007

21

7 3.4 weeks

August, 2008

20 6 3 weeks
August, 2009* 20 5 6 weeks
August, 2010 47 6 11.5 weeks

Health Partner's: Prenatal appointments in Norristown 

Health Partner's

# of Practitioners     Listed

# of Individual Practitioners    Available

Average wait time for an appointment

August, 2005

22

7

N/A

August, 2006

38

4

4 weeks

August, 2007

10

5 3.1 weeks

August, 2008

6 7 4 weeks
August, 2009* 7 1 1 day
August, 2010 47 6 11.5 weeks

*In 2009, the search radius for Health Partners was extended to 15 miles because no providers appeared when searching within 5 miles. 

 

Aetna Better Health: Prenatal appointments in Norristown

Aetna Better Health

 

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners Available

Average wait time for an appointment

August, 2010 47 0 N/A

This health plan was established in April 2010. While Montgomery Hospital accepts this health plan, the practitioners providing care at the maternity clinic do not.

 

 

CoventryCares: Prenatal appointments in Norristown

CoventryCares

# of Practitioners Listed

# of Individual Practitioners Available

Average wait time for an appointment

August, 2010 47 0 N/A

This health plan was established in April 2010. While Montgomery Hospital accepts this health plan, the practitioners providing care at the maternity clinic do not.

 

 

 

Each year we document the reasons that so many listings are inaccurate.  The pie charts below show the reasons for inaccuracies and their frequency.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Norristown Sister Speak Out 2010

"The Prenatal Care Experiences of African American Women in Norristown." MCC, the Norristown Alliance for Healthy Babies and the Montgomery County Health Department recently conducted a study of the barriers to prenatal care access.  In January 2010, African American women came together to discuss the report and the challenges they face in accessing prenatal care and ensuring for themselves a healthy pregnancy and a healthy newborn.  Read it here!

Read the Report

As moderator for the event Shamara, POWR99 FM mid-day host, took comments from audience members.

Panelists (left to right): Bertha Staples-Tucker, mother and Social Worker at Laurel House and Norristown Family Center; Jasmine White, local mom and participant in the Norristown Alliance for Healthy Babies Report.

Brownsyne Tucker Edmonds, MD, MPH

responds to the report findings.

Event moderator Shamara joins Montgomery County Department of Health's Dr. Joseph DiMino, Medical Director (center) and Barbara Hand, Infant Health Coordinator (second from left, standing); MCC staff members Olivia Hamilton, Prenatal Outreach Coordinator (on right, seated) and Cynthia Waters, Director of Operations (on far right, standing) along with the event panelists.

Panelists Yasmeen Davis, MOMobile advocate, with Nurse midwife at Montgomery Hospital, Crystal Franklin.
 

Philadelphia in Philadelphia County

In 2007, there were three managed care organizations (MCOs) that offer plans to Medicaid recipients: Keystone Mercy Health Plan, AmeriChoice, and Health Partners. In our Survey of Prenatal Care Availability for Medicaid Managed Care Recipients in Philadelphia, MCC found that:

  • The directories were more than 85% inaccurate. 
  • Listed practitioners frequently were no longer available; the phone number was wrong; or the site listed no longer offered prenatal care. 
  • Out of 1,500+ listings, only 139 practitioners at 61 prenatal care sites were available. 
  • The waiting time for an initial appointment averaged just above the two-week standard.     

The consequences of inaccurate information were recognized and policy changes have been implemented by some of the MCOs and the Department of Public Welfare to assure consumers have accurate and easily accessible information. 

 
 
 

Please visit our Childbirth Crisis News page to read recent articles or Take Action on important issues!

 
Last Updated January 2011

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Home  |  About  |  Programs  |  Events  |  Resources  |  News  |  Donate  |  Contact  |  Site Map  |  Search  |  Privacy

   

©Copyright 2005. All Rights Reserved. Maternity Care Coalition
2000 Hamilton St, Suite 205, Philadelphia, PA 19130
Phone: 215.972.0700, Fax: 215.972.8266, : mcc@MOMobile.org